Lauren Smith
This report repeats 1 earlier warning. See the linked reports.
The coroner's concerns
1. incorrect ecg interpretation leading to missed acute myocardial infarction
“An ecg reading was taken at 08:56 am when both the paramedic and technician were in attendance on Miss [name redacted]. That ecg was abnormal. The ecg identified pathological Q waves in V1, V2 and V3, an isolated ST elevation in V2 and a positive AVR deflection. Although the rhythm was sinus rhythm, 3 abnormal indicators were clearly present on the ecg. In addition, the auto diagnostic monitor clearly recorded the ecg as abnormal and reported an anterior infarct which was available for attending paramedics.”
2. failure to act on abnormal ecg results
“I am concerned that neither the paramedic nor the technician was able to interpret the ecg correctly and that neither paramedic appears to have noted or acted upon the auto diagnostic monitor report.”
3. miscommunication of ecg results influencing patient decision
“[the deceased] was informed that her observations and ecg were normal. This information was not correct, and it is likely that [the deceased] based her decision not to attend hospital on this incorrect information.”
4. absence of organisational learning from incident
“I am concerned that there has been no collective learning by West Midlands Ambulance Service following the death of [REDACTED]. There has been no action to address the learning gaps identified by WMAS own internal investigation report in respect of both the paramedic and technician.”
Linked reports
Earlier report
“one of the paramedics who qualified in 2015 after a 2 year foundation degree gave evidence that he had never had any formal testing on interpretation of 12 lead ECG”
This report
“Paramedic [REDACTED] gave evidence at inquest that she'd never heard of Q waves before and didn't see the ST elevation on the ecg”
Responses
2023-0454-Response-from-Care-Quality-Commission.pdf ↗· Care Quality Commission
Stated action
“We will continue to monitor WMAS's progress in making improvements to their serious incident management and learning from deaths through our ongoing monitoring activities and engagement.”
2023-0454-Response-from-Health-and-Care-Professions-Council-1.pdf ↗· Health and Care Professions Council
2023-0454-Response-from-Health-Services-Safety-Investigations-Body.pdf ↗· Health Services Safety Investigations Body
2023-0454-Response-from-University-of-Wolverhampton.pdf ↗· Wolverhampton University
2023-0454-Response-from-West-Midlands-Ambulance-Service.pdf ↗· West Midlands Ambulance Service University NHS Foundation Trust