Stephen Chapple and Jennifer Chapple
28 Feb 2023 · Coroner Samantha Marsh · Somerset
The coroner's concerns
1. deadly weapon
“Please reconsider the appropriateness of providing anyone leaving the British Army, regardless of rank or status, with what is (to all intents and purposes) a deadly weapon. Such presentation/gifting has essentially put a deadly weapon in the community (where I understand it sadly remains, having never been recovered as it was removed from the scene prior to police attendance) and I am not persuaded that this is appropriate.”
2. mental health issues
“During the trial, evidence was adduced by [REDACTED] defence team to allude to the poor mental health of [REDACTED] because of combat and tours of war-torn countries. This is not an uncommon feature of those serving in and/or leaving the Army and adds further weight to my concerns around the appropriateness of such items (whether ceremonial or not) being issued in the first place, but secondly being issued to those who may have a propensity for mental health issues.”
Responses
2023-0073-Response-from-Ministry-of-Defence-.pdf ↗· Ministry of Defence
Stated action
“To ensure there is genuine requirement to issue such items to personnel.”